Pipelines for public service?
Increasingly over the past few weeks, Premier Rachel Notley and her government have been working hard to draw a connection between the funding of public services in Alberta and the construction of the TransMountain pipeline—from press releases, to tweets, to Health Minister Sarah Hoffmann’s assertion at the Western Premiers’ Conference last month that “pharmacare doesn’t grow on trees.”
This type of messaging from the NDP is a significant reversal of its previous standpoint that neither our economy nor our government revenues should be as dependent on oil and gas as they currently are, and its opinion that the province’s level of natural resource revenue should never be the determining factor in how we fund our public services and infrastructure.
In fact, the NDP has often argued, in the past, that we should be saving as much of our natural resource revenue as possible and primarily relying on a fair and progressive system of taxes to fund our public services and infrastructure.
All of that, however, appears to have been tossed out the proverbial window as part of the government’s quest for popular support in this all-consuming effort to get the pipeline built.
More concerning than the NDP’s recent about-face on how we fund public services, however, is what their new positioning will actually mean for the funding of those services over the next few years.
The path to fiscal balance identified in Budget 2018, which presumes that the pipeline will be built, shows overall spending growth in Alberta not keeping up with population growth and inflation in order to balance the books by 2023. What this means for things like health care and education in the province is a virtual funding cut of between 15 and 20 percent over the next five years. In other words, it appears from the government’s own projections that even with the TransMountain pipeline we will not have the revenues we need to adequately fund our public services.
Unfortunately, despite what it says in Budget 2018, the real scope of the problem will be much worse than that, considering the government based its numbers on some fairly inflated projections for the fiscal, and economic benefits that would result from the completion of the pipeline.
The government’s job numbers, for example, are based on modeling conducted by the Conference Board of Canada that economists of all stripes have now repeatedly, and soundly, discredited. The only enduring numbers are those provided by Kinder Morgan with their initial pipeline application: 2,500 construction jobs per year for two years, and 50 permanent operations jobs in Alberta and 40 in British Columbia. Given Alberta’s ridiculously low tax rates, there is no way the pipeline expansion alone will generate the growth in tax revenues projected by the government.
This is also true for the projected growth in jobs from increased bitumen production. The industry has changed significantly in the last five years making bitumen extraction much less labour intensive than it used to be.
This is also the case with the government’s estimates for increased royalties as a result of higher prices. The future price and royalty projections are based almost entirely on a price differential that was inflated because of a shutdown and subsequent reduced capacity in the Keystone Pipeline. As that pipeline comes back to full capacity, the tidewater price differential will come back down to historical averages meaning the price obtained per barrel will not be significantly higher, if at all.
In the end, it does seem that the NDP had it right historically—it is absolute insanity to tie funding for public services to the price and well-being of the oil industry. However, a two percent sales tax in Alberta would generate over $3 billion a year in government revenues. And adopting the tax structure and regime of B.C., the next-lowest-taxed province, would generate an extra $11.2 billion per year.
Perhaps if the government had gone back to its roots, and put as much energy and political capital into fixing our tax system as they have into building this pipeline, they really would have found a way to fund health care and education sustainably over the long term. In the meantime, I guess we just brace for the cuts that will come regardless of what happens with the pipeline.

Leave a Comment X